Short Film
"Hermanos"
29 October 2024
22 mins 01s

Hermanos
When telling a story rooted in truth, it can be immensely important to avoid the trap of oversimplification in search of a more dramatic narrative, and Rachel McDonald, who wrote and directed this deeply affecting film, clearly has an innate understanding of this. She uses the tropes of a story which has the appearance of an odyssey to lull the audience into thinking they are perhaps going to see an unlikely adventure. The two Mexican boys (played by newcomers Seth Gutierrez and Carlos Sanchez) are way out of their depth as they escape the custody of the US authorities in the ambitious hope of finding their aunt. Instead of suddenly developing an extraordinary level of competence, they remain close to where they escaped without appearing to have an idea how to achieve their objective and, by keeping the duo grounded in this fashion, McDonald keeps her film grounded in the reality of the plight of children like her protagonists. Instead of unlikely heroics, the film focuses on the children's back story, with glimpses of the life they had in Mexico, and a clear signal of why their mother opted to flee across the border. The film aims to humanise the people who are usually anonymised by sensational news coverage driven by a political battle which, at times, appears to be an effort by one side to maximise the cruelty, and not much better from the other.
USA
Short Film
|